Upon the player's final death, they will be presented with a 'You Suck' message. Finally, if the player dies too many times, 33 to be exact, the rainbow will lose patience with the player and, after they respawn, will shoot lasers from its eyes continuously until the player dies one last time and gets booted from the minigame. The more the player dies, the ruder Chica's Magic Rainbow's comments will become, going from slightly annoyed and wanting to leave, to mild insults and then to outright swearing. Its pleasant attitude slowly starts to deteriorate as the game progresses. The rainbow starts by introducing the player to her 'happy fun rainbow land' and motivating the player with encouraging remarks. The player must avoid sunflowers that shoot their petals in eight directions, wooden spikes that pop out of the ground (and in one case, the sky), and logs that are hurled at Chica, while the rainbow itself shoots lasers and its eyeballs in an attempt to kill the player. The mechanics for jumping are intentionally made to be very precise and frustrating, as Chica will stop going up and immediately start falling the moment the player lets go of the jump button.
The player controls Chica and moves around through a seemingly innocuous course, which is soon revealed to be filled with traps. The course in general functions like a basic platforming side-scroller.